Since it is the season for holiday parties, it seemed prudent to remind you all that DWI Checkpoints are legal in Louisiana and have been determined to be so by the Louisiana Supreme Court since 2000. In State v. Jackson, 2000-0015 (La. 7/6/00); 764 So.2d 64, the Louisiana Supreme Court found that DWI checkpoints could satisfy the limitations of the Louisiana constitution if they met certain requirements:

[W]e set forth the following guidelines for evaluating whether the checkpoint's intrusiveness will withstand constitutional muster under the Fourth Amendment and Louisiana's Article I, § 5:17

(1) the location, time and duration of a checkpoint, and other regulations for operation of the checkpoint, preferably in written form, established by supervisory or other administrative personnel rather than the field officers implementing the checkpoint;

(2) advance warning to the approaching motorist with signs, flares and other indications to warn of the impending stop in a safe manner and to provide notice of its official nature as a police checkpoint;

(3) detention of the motorist for a minimal length of time; and

(4) use of a systematic nonrandom criteria for stopping motorists.

In evaluating a checkpoint under this test, the guiding principle must be that the procedures utilized curtail the unbridled discretion of the officer in the field. Prouse, 440 U.S. at 662, 99 S.Ct. 1391; **12 Brown, 443 U.S. at 51, 99 S.Ct. 2637.

State v. Jackson, 2000-0015 (La. 7/6/00, 11–12); 764 So.2d 64, 72–73.

Subsequently, the Louisiana Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal held that the act of attempting to avoid a checkpoint was sufficient to establish reasonable suspicion to detain a driver and conduct further investigation.

If you are out celebrating the holidays with friends and loved ones, please drive carefully and safely.

And if you would like to set up a consult, give us a call at (318) 459-9111.

Both the United States Constitution and the Louisiana State Constitution, according to the US Supreme Court and the Louisiana Supreme Court, allow for law enforcement to set up checkpoints for various offenses. The Courts have allowed for checkpoints for the purpose of stopping and arresting intoxicated drivers, people operating their vehicles without insurance and without seatbelts, among other things.

In order for a checkpoint to pass constitutional muster, it must meet some requirements:

1. The location, time, and duration of the checkpoint, as well as any other regulations governing the operation of the checkpoint must be established by supervisory or administrative personnel with the law enforcement agency who are not involved in the operation of the checkpoint, itself. It is not required, but the cases recommend that these regulations be memorialized in writing.)

2. The law agency must provide advance warning to motorists using signs, flares, or other indicators of the official nature of the checkpoint.

3. The motorists must be detained for a minimal period of time.
   and

4. The officers must use a systematic, nonrandom criteria for stopping motorists.

The purpose of these rules is the “curtail the unbridled discretion of officers in the field.” State v. Jackson, 764 So.2d 64 (2000).

If you have questions about an arrest arising from a law enforcement checkpoint, call us at (318) 459-9111.